top of page

Fach

  • Writer: Amanda Riddell
    Amanda Riddell
  • May 2, 2025
  • 2 min read

One of my perennial irritations is that the opera singers scoffed at my claims of being a unicorn. Baryton-martin is quite a rare voice type. John Raitt had it, and Don's probably got it too (that's how he hits the pure high notes). - Essentially I can hit a Bb or B with power - as in the 'heavy fall' climax of These Words Are Meant For Someone - yet still get below the C below middle C. Tenors can't really do that. Opera singers scoffed at the idea of me writing one as well thanks to all that anti-light opera, anti-musicals bs ... now they're believing, but they're still treating it as if I want to be a singer. It's exploitative to tell me to do a role in The Perfumed Garden, and from my POV it's essentially an excuse to limit my opportunities for creative input during rehearsals. - It's also about technique, not just raw voice power. One thing I read online years ago was that to sing really well as a baritone, then you should blend chest and head voice from around the A below middle C. It's a French thing re: the tone. Yes, I can sing, but I'm hardly Pavarotti. Others can sing better, while I write well. It's only a demonstration, not an audition. I'm doing it for fun, and that's why it's fun. It's not fun to socialise with arrogant, conceited, vain people. Singers and actors... Not going to be talked into it: if you want to do the opera I'm writing, then you'll need to respect me as a composer and allow me to handle the fine details that a composer is typically in charge of during a show.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
To my stalkers

Look, if you want a better outcome, then you have to meet me IRL. I can moan and shout in my little room as much as I like, but it's futile. The police are investigating: I'm not going to close the i

 
 
 
Working For Each Other: what's it about?

Well, with my films, we don't usually know until the end. My main argument is that the film was the outgrowth of Paul and I taking LSD. The film began with a song written during the trip and took thr

 
 
 
To Mendes people

Sondheim believed in exclusively speaking ill of the dead. The circumstances of his death need to be public. You can't protect his legacy that way. Your loved one was willing to kill Sir Paul and Mic

 
 
 

3 Comments


Amanda Riddell
Amanda Riddell
May 01, 2025

Most vocal composers can sing a bit, and some are genuinely good. That's my point: Alex Taylor and Gareth get the benefit of the doubt; I don't.


None of the singer Kiwis are aware of classical guitar, so they essentially thought that I was a rock star with ideas above my station. I'm not Tim Finn, though I'd also qualify that by saying that all that hierarchical nonsense is why concert music and opera are dying. Tim's got a fabulous voice, much better than mine. He wasn't in his musical or opera, though given this bullshit I'm sure he had to negotiate that as well.

Edited
Like
Amanda Riddell
Amanda Riddell
May 01, 2025
Replying to

Why are my brother and I decently good at projecting? Choir experience, but also that we largely abhor microphones, and enjoy all that tramping sing-song stuff.

Like
bottom of page