top of page

snark

Writer: Amanda Riddell
Amanda Riddell
Oct 26, 2023
1 min read

Ok, so everyone likes to compare my musical to Rent or Hamilton or Hair, but they're completely forgetting that the first rock musical was Bye Bye Birdie, and that also features teenagers in revolt against 'the man'. Difference here is that Albert is the focus in Bye Bye Birdie, while Jo is the focus for Shipwrecked on Islands. Strouse is one of my favourite composers, and those Ginzler orchestrations on the original album are the best of any show ever imo. Whether We're Rich or Poor is like Rosie, though obviously it's a folk song rather than one of my own compositions. I think the interpolations in the Shipwrecked score were quite effective, and felt cohesive. - Joe Dante hates that Jason Alexander version, but I think it's a fair, solid version of the show. I can't stand the 1960's movie, though... I hate most of the 1960's movie musicals.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Forbes announcement

Paul has been back in the three comma club for a few months now. When Working For Each Other first paid off, he paid off his debts. That was around $100 million. - Paul's affairs are worth a lot mo

 
 
 
Lisa The Vegetarian

I was watching it again... Fairly sure that's not Paul's voice in the dialogue or the credits song. It's probably Dan Castallaneta.

 
 
 
Amanda's Top 20 (classical/instrumental)

I Te Pō Katoa - Lullaby Chloefilm Vanya's Lament Dream Sequence (Portrait of a Knight) Piano Trio - first movement Parliament Grounds Rhapsody for Guitar and Viola 'Oro's Dances String Quartet - Golri

 
 
 

1 Comment


Amanda Riddell
Amanda Riddell
Oct 25, 2023

Stray thought: what if we copied the Second Civil War and had Edgar and Rose as a thing? I figure Jo starts singing Whether We're Rich or Poor, then Nate, Pandora etc. join in for the final A of the first chorus. Then there's some dialogue... then everyone picks up the tune until 'so if you'll bank on me' -- that's when Edgar sings the solo to Rose. 🥝

Like
bottom of page